Anecdotal reports sometimes portray AA as confrontational, but these may be confusing AA with reports of step-oriented professional counselors.
Paul psychiatrist, winced when I mentioned this. A report by the National Center on Addiction and Substance Abuse at Columbia University compared the current state of addiction medicine to general medicine in the early s, when quacks worked alongside graduates of leading medical schools. In fact, anger is the only construct in the AA literature for which a detailed column-based worksheet is provided to help members document, analyze, and remediate angry thoughts and feelings AA, The Science article received widespread attention, including a story in The New York Times and a segment on 60 Minutes.
Though the paper was filled with caveats about its lack of scientific rigor, it became AA gospel. Nathan et al.
The irrationality of alcoholics anonymous
A large number of research studies during the past 25 years have indicated that AA is helpful to many different types of individuals in their recovery efforts Emrick et al. Sinclair called this the alcohol-deprivation effect, and his laboratory results, which have since been confirmed by many other studies, suggested a fundamental flaw in abstinence-based treatment: going cold turkey only intensifies cravings. Where we get into trouble is when we start trying to control, manipulate or dominate our feelings and hungers as though they were objects like tables, chairs, cars, and money. And now that naltrexone is available in an inexpensive generic form, pharmaceutical companies have little incentive to promote it. It doesn't really matter. For a glimpse of how treatment works elsewhere, I traveled to Finland, a country that shares with the United States a history of prohibition inspired by the American temperance movement, the Finns outlawed alcohol from to and a culture of heavy drinking. Shame This is where shame enters the picture. The AA core literature explicitly describes the AA approach as one of respect and explicitly nonconfrontational AA, By necessity, it keeps no records of who attends meetings; members come and go and are, of course, anonymous. The results have been largely overlooked. By the time he was a practicing defense attorney, J. His optimism is particularly poignant: in , he lost a son to a drug overdose.
A year-old doctor and university researcher, he describes himself as mild-mannered while sober. However, AA attendance was unrelated to changes in anger.
Alcoholics anonymous complaints
The drug helped subjects keep from going over the legal threshold for intoxication, a blood alcohol content of 0. Anger, irritability, depression, boredom, and other indices of negative affect have all been implicated in a stress-induced pathway to relapse among alcohol and other drug-dependent individuals Cummings et al. The prospect of never taking another sip is daunting, to say the least. For-profit rehab facilities sprouted across the country, the beginnings of what would become a multibillion-dollar industry. The United States is a country which accepts religious freedom, and so anyone who chooses may go to AA. A Maryland Court decided that even telling people that they must declare that they are alcoholics was an impermissible intrusion on individual freedom of choice and conscience. But many in AA and the rehab industry insist the 12 steps are the only answer and frown on using the prescription drugs that have been shown to help people reduce their drinking. Fourteen states had no license requirements for addiction counselors—not even a GED or an introductory course. He has successfully drunk in moderation on occasion, without any loss of control or desire to consume more the next day. J Stud Alcohol Drugs. Stripped of associated shame, an analysis of the event of a relapse to alcohol can now point the way to doing things in a different, safer way in the future. When I asked how much all of this cost, Keski-Pukkila looked uneasy. The new term replaces the older alcohol abuse and the much more dated alcoholism, which has been out of favor with researchers for decades. Evening would fall and his heart would race as he thought ahead to another sleepless night. Understanding Alcoholism Another way to get at what AA is saying is that - if we want to stop drinking - we must trade in a dysfunctional and shame-producing way of thinking about our alcoholism for one that is less conducive to shame.
In fact, in a growing number of states, courts have rejected compulsory AA attendance. We admitted we were powerless over alcohol - that our lives had become unmanageable.
He has successfully drunk in moderation on occasion, without any loss of control or desire to consume more the next day.
based on 90 review